Difference between revisions of "Public Interest Test"

From FOIwiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(EIR guidelines)
(Public Interest Test)
 
(17 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
JnXZsi  <a href="http://anabrhtixisk.com/">anabrhtixisk</a>, [url=http://chxyhqqftnxv.com/]chxyhqqftnxv[/url], [link=http://kemasnfncghz.com/]kemasnfncghz[/link], http://tbxrflgxbknw.com/
+
== Public Interest Test ==
  
http://kost5478.fusedtree.com/ personal action plan
+
Many of the exemptions that exist in the laws are "qualified exemptions". These are subject to a "public interest test" which is designed to weigh up and compare the arguments in favour of giving out information against those arguments against.
http://greyy358.700megs.com/ easy hair ideas
 
http://vily7788.hostshield.com/ and red alert 3
 
http://lolo002.110mb.com/ gaara dance
 
http://roma0009.freewhost.com/ language culture program
 
http://aura22.phreesite.com/ list of birth defects
 
http://bulki843.my3gb.com/ liquid diet and
 
http://kost5478.fusedtree.com/example-of-personal-development-plan.html personal learning plan template
 
http://greyy358.700megs.com/straight-hair-ideas.html african american hair ideas
 
http://vily7788.hostshield.com/westwood-red-alert-3.html red alert 3 cheat
 
http://lolo002.110mb.com/gaara-happy.html gaara costumes
 
http://roma0009.freewhost.com/russian-language-and-culture.html culture shock language
 
http://aura22.phreesite.com/causing-birth-defects.html severe birth defects
 
http://bulki843.my3gb.com/what-is-a-liquid-diet.html liquid diet &
 
http://kost5478.fusedtree.com/personal-saving-plan.html a personal action plan
 
http://greyy358.700megs.com/hair-cut-ideas-men.html celebrity hair cut ideas
 
http://vily7788.hostshield.com/a-red-alert-3.html command and conquer red alert 3 units
 
http://lolo002.110mb.com/new-gaara.html gaara deck
 
http://roma0009.freewhost.com/language-reflects-culture.html language shapes culture
 
http://aura22.phreesite.com/india-birth-defects.html articles on birth defects
 
http://bulki843.my3gb.com/what-is-a-clear-liquid-diet.html liquid diet products
 
http://kost5478.fusedtree.com/a-personal-five-year-plan.html how to plan a personal
 
http://greyy358.700megs.com/red-hair-color-ideas.html curly hair color ideas
 
http://vily7788.hostshield.com/red-alert-3-cover.html red alert 3 new units
 
http://lolo002.110mb.com/gaara-killing.html gaara amvs
 
http://roma0009.freewhost.com/for-language--culture.html the role of language in culture
 
http://aura22.phreesite.com/national-birth-defect.html california birth defect
 
http://bulki843.my3gb.com/liquid-diet-side.html a liquid diet work
 
http://kost5478.fusedtree.com/motors-personal-savings-plan.html personal budget plan template
 
http://vily7788.hostshield.com/cheats-for-red-alert-2.html westwood red alert 2
 
http://lolo002.110mb.com/gaara-tutorial.html gaara movies
 
http://roma0009.freewhost.com/culture-language-laws.html in which the language reflects the culture and its
 
http://aura22.phreesite.com/birth-defect-pics.html birth defects wiki
 
  
http://kost5703.110mb.com/ prison break 2008 season
+
The other kind of exemptions are known as "[[absolute exemptions]]".
http://acum765.50webs.com/ family guy to watch online
 
http://vasi8951.fizwig.com/ lf2 5 cheat codes
 
http://livee57.rack111.com/ rifle calibers
 
http://optik84.my3gb.com/ restaurant trade associations
 
http://amin1195.007gb.com/ worms 4 trainer
 
http://vasi5009.001webs.com/ adobe photoshop cs2 serial numbers
 
http://kost5703.110mb.com/prison-break-season-five.html prison break season 4 filming
 
http://acum765.50webs.com/watch-family-guy-com.html watch family guy stewie kills lois
 
http://vasi8951.fizwig.com/v4-5-cheat-codes.html 5 1 0 cheat codes
 
http://livee57.rack111.com/rifle-for-sale.html rifle scabbard
 
http://optik84.my3gb.com/texas-trade-associations.html healthcare trade associations
 
http://amin1195.007gb.com/avernum-4-trainer.html sa trainer 4
 
http://vasi5009.001webs.com/adobe-photoshop-cs2-serial-crack.html adobe photoshop 10 serial
 
http://kost5703.110mb.com/prison-break-new-season-starts.html when is prison break season 4 starting
 
http://acum765.50webs.com/watch-new-family-guy-episode.html watch family guy deep throats
 
http://vasi8951.fizwig.com/5-cheat-codes-to.html 5 pc cheat
 
http://livee57.rack111.com/military-surplus-rifle.html colt rifle
 
http://optik84.my3gb.com/packaging-trade-associations.html packaging trade associations
 
http://amin1195.007gb.com/demonic-defense-4-trainer.html 4 pc game trainer
 
http://vasi5009.001webs.com/photoshop-5-serial-number.html photoshop 7.0 serial numbers
 
http://kost5703.110mb.com/what-happened-to-prison-break-season-3.html prison break season four trailer
 
http://acum765.50webs.com/watch-family-guy-e.html watch family guy fast
 
http://vasi8951.fizwig.com/arms-5-cheat-codes.html cheat codes for tekken 5 on
 
http://livee57.rack111.com/surplus-rifle-com.html the rifle man
 
http://optik84.my3gb.com/consulting-trade-associations.html new jersey trade associations
 
http://amin1195.007gb.com/4-plus-6-trainer.html call of duty 4 trainer v1
 
http://vasi5009.001webs.com/photoshop-cs-serial-number.html photoshop 10.0 serial
 
http://kost5703.110mb.com/when-will-prison-break-season-4.html prison break season 3 episode names
 
http://acum765.50webs.com/watch-family-guy-on-wii.html watch family guy online free
 
http://vasi8951.fizwig.com/dynasty-warriors-5-xbox-cheat.html might and magic 5 tribes of the east cheat codes
 
http://livee57.rack111.com/lever-rifle.html rifle serial numbers
 
http://optik84.my3gb.com/pennsylvania-trade-associations.html trade associations in texas
 
http://amin1195.007gb.com/cry-4-mega-trainer.html strategy defense 4 trainer
 
http://vasi5009.001webs.com/photoshop-serial-number.html get photoshop serial
 
http://kost5703.110mb.com/watch-prison-break-season-2-episode-5.html watch online prison break season 3 episode
 
  
http://nova2846.my3gb.com/ books to kill a mockingbird
+
See also: [[Winning the Public Interest Argument]].
http://gregorydy358.700megs.com/ microsoft office outlook offline
+
 
http://breez421.50webs.com/ broccoli casserole recipes
+
== United Kingdom FOIA guidelines ==
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/ cbs sportsline fantasy football
+
 
http://vasi4450.freewhost.com/ heroes of the pacific patch
+
* Information that is of "Public Interest", means that it is in the something which serves the interests of the public, not something that might be interesting!
http://romma211.rack111.com/ watch er season 13 online
+
* The public authority has to decide whether in any particular case it serves the interests of the public better to withhold or to disclose information.
http://yura0122.fizwig.com/ definitely maybe review
+
* The starting point should always be of disclosure to avoid bias
http://nova2846.my3gb.com/to-kill-a-mockingbird-quizzes.html to kill a mockingbird project
+
* They should list all the points in favour of disclosure
http://gregorydy358.700megs.com/instal-microsoft-office.html microsoft office 2007 simplified
+
* They should then list all the points against disclosure
http://breez421.50webs.com/chicken-rice-casserole-recipes.html taco casserole recipe
+
* They should then say where the overall balance lies and give reasons as to why.
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/fantasy-football-guide.html free fantasy football leagues
+
 
http://vasi4450.freewhost.com/the-patch.html the patch
+
* http://www.justice.gov.uk/guidance/foi-exemptions-public-interest.htm
http://romma211.rack111.com/watch-er-tv-show.html watch er finale
+
* http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/library/freedom_of_information/detailed_specialist_guides/awareness_guidance_3_public_interest_test.pdf
http://yura0122.fizwig.com/definitely-maybe-divx.html definitely maybe jane
+
 
http://nova2846.my3gb.com/to-kill-a-mockingbird-help.html to kill a mockingbird mockingbird
+
== Scottish FOISA guidelines ==
http://gregorydy358.700megs.com/microsoft-visual-studio-tools-for-the-microsoft-office-system.html microsoft office enterprise 2007 encountered an error during setup
+
 
http://breez421.50webs.com/vegetarian-casserole-recipe.html chop casserole recipes
+
Paraphrased from the [http://www.itspublicknowledge.info/Law/FOISA-EIRsGuidance/ThePublicInterestTest/thePublicInterestTest.asp SIC guidance]:
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/fantasy-football-trophy.html fantasy football info
+
* The public interest is not defined in FOISA but has been described as "something which is of serious concern and benefit to the public"
http://vasi4450.freewhost.com/the-paper-patch.html the warriors patch
+
* The "public" in this context does not necessarily mean the entire population. It might relate to a relatively localised public (e.g. a small community or interest group) or to the wider public at large.
http://romma211.rack111.com/can-i-watch-er-season.html watch er as the  
+
* The Section 60 Code of Practice gives advice to public authorities on applying the test
http://yura0122.fizwig.com/definitely-maybe-tv.html about definitely maybe
+
::*The Section 60 Code notes that the following factors should not be taken into account when applying the public interest test.
http://nova2846.my3gb.com/review-of-to-kill-a-mockingbird.html review on to kill a mockingbird
+
::*possible embarrassment of government or other public authority officials;
http://gregorydy358.700megs.com/microsoft-office-proffesional-plus-2007.html manually uninstall microsoft office
+
::*the seniority of persons involved in the subject matter;
http://breez421.50webs.com/lentil-casserole-recipe.html lasagna casserole recipe
+
::*the risk of the applicant misinterpreting the information.
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/fantasy-football-magazine.html barclays premiership fantasy football
+
::*possible loss of confidence in government or other public authority
http://vasi4450.freewhost.com/the-party-patch.html the political machine patch
+
* The complexity of the information is not a valid reason for withholding information
http://romma211.rack111.com/watch-the-season-finale-of-er.html watch er season 13 online
+
 
http://yura0122.fizwig.com/definitely-maybe-phone.html definitely maybe rental
+
== EIR guidelines ==
http://nova2846.my3gb.com/house-in-to-kill-a-mockingbird.html to kill a mockingbird book characters
+
 
http://gregorydy358.700megs.com/microsoft-officeexcel.html microsoft office proffessional plus
+
tbc
http://breez421.50webs.com/hamburger-potato-casserole-recipe.html tamale casserole recipes
 
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/fantasy-football-prizes.html barclay fantasy football
 
http://vasi4450.freewhost.com/the-calico-patch.html the pineapple patch
 
http://yura0122.fizwig.com/the-book-in-definitely-maybe.html from definitely maybe the movie
 
http://breez421.50webs.com/chicken-noodle-casserole-recipe.html chicken noodle casserole recipe
 
http://yura0555.hostshield.com/free-fantasy-football-mock-draft.html fantasy football programs
 
  
 
== EIR Scotland guidelines  ==
 
== EIR Scotland guidelines  ==

Latest revision as of 20:57, 11 July 2009

Public Interest Test

Many of the exemptions that exist in the laws are "qualified exemptions". These are subject to a "public interest test" which is designed to weigh up and compare the arguments in favour of giving out information against those arguments against.

The other kind of exemptions are known as "absolute exemptions".

See also: Winning the Public Interest Argument.

United Kingdom FOIA guidelines

  • Information that is of "Public Interest", means that it is in the something which serves the interests of the public, not something that might be interesting!
  • The public authority has to decide whether in any particular case it serves the interests of the public better to withhold or to disclose information.
  • The starting point should always be of disclosure to avoid bias
  • They should list all the points in favour of disclosure
  • They should then list all the points against disclosure
  • They should then say where the overall balance lies and give reasons as to why.

Scottish FOISA guidelines

Paraphrased from the SIC guidance:

  • The public interest is not defined in FOISA but has been described as "something which is of serious concern and benefit to the public"
  • The "public" in this context does not necessarily mean the entire population. It might relate to a relatively localised public (e.g. a small community or interest group) or to the wider public at large.
  • The Section 60 Code of Practice gives advice to public authorities on applying the test
  • The Section 60 Code notes that the following factors should not be taken into account when applying the public interest test.
  • possible embarrassment of government or other public authority officials;
  • the seniority of persons involved in the subject matter;
  • the risk of the applicant misinterpreting the information.
  • possible loss of confidence in government or other public authority
  • The complexity of the information is not a valid reason for withholding information

EIR guidelines

tbc

EIR Scotland guidelines

The public interest test is similar to that in section 2(1)(b) of the FOISA. Under the EIRs, a Scottish public authority may only refuse to make environmental information available if the public interest in making it available is outweighed by that in maintaining the relevant exception.

However, regulation 10(2)(b) builds in a presumption in favour of disclosure which means that where arguments are evenly balanced for withholding and disclosing the information, the information must be disclosed.

Scottish Information Commissioner guidance.

Freedom of Information Act 2000 - What the law says

2 Effect of the exemptions in Part II
(1) Where any provision of Part II states that the duty to confirm or deny does not arise in relation to any information, the effect of the provision is that where either—
(a) the provision confers absolute exemption, or
(b) in all the circumstances of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exclusion of the duty to confirm or deny outweighs the public interest in disclosing whether the public authority holds the information,

section 1(1)(a) does not apply.

(2) In respect of any information which is exempt information by virtue of any provision of Part II, section 1(1)(b) does not apply if or to the extent that—
(a) the information is exempt information by virtue of a provision conferring absolute exemption, or
(b) in all the circumstances of the case, the public interest in maintaining the exemption outweighs the public interest in disclosing the information.
Freedom of Information Act 2000.