FS50125005: Difference between revisions
From FOIwiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Alex skene (talk | contribs) (XML import) |
Alex skene (talk | contribs) (CSV import) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{DNSummaryBox | |||
|dn_ref=FS50125005 | |dn_ref=FS50125005 | ||
|dn_date=17 | |dn_date=17 June 2009 | ||
|dn_pa=Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council | |dn_pa=Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council | ||
|dn_summary=The complainant requested information about a proposal to redevelop a shopping centre in the centre of a village, Hale Barns, in Cheshire. The council is the freeholder of the property which is held on a long term lease by the developer. The council provided some information to the complainant however it withheld other information under the exemptions in sections 43 (commercial interests), 41 (information held in confidence) and 40 (personal data) of the Act. It also withheld other information under Section 36 of the Act (the effective conduct of public affairs); however after it was directed by the Commissioner to reconsider this information under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 it amended this to Regulations 12(4)(e) (internal communications), 12(5)(e) (the confidentiality of commercial or industrial information) and 12(5)(f) (confidential information provided on a voluntary basis). The Commissioner's decision is that the council withheld some of information appropriately under sections 43, 40 and 41 but other information should have been disclosed. Under the Regulations his decision is that some information was appropriately withheld under Regulations 12(4)(e), 12(5)(e), and 12(5)(f) however other information could not be withheld under these Regulations. | |dn_summary=The complainant requested information about a proposal to redevelop a shopping centre in the centre of a village, Hale Barns, in Cheshire. The council is the freeholder of the property which is held on a long term lease by the developer. The council provided some information to the complainant however it withheld other information under the exemptions in sections 43 (commercial interests), 41 (information held in confidence) and 40 (personal data) of the Act. It also withheld other information under Section 36 of the Act (the effective conduct of public affairs); however after it was directed by the Commissioner to reconsider this information under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 it amended this to Regulations 12(4)(e) (internal communications), 12(5)(e) (the confidentiality of commercial or industrial information) and 12(5)(f) (confidential information provided on a voluntary basis). The Commissioner's decision is that the council withheld some of information appropriately under sections 43, 40 and 41 but other information should have been disclosed. Under the Regulations his decision is that some information was appropriately withheld under Regulations 12(4)(e), 12(5)(e), and 12(5)(f) however other information could not be withheld under these Regulations. | ||
|dn_url=http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/decisionnotices/2009/fs_50125005.pdf | |dn_url=http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/decisionnotices/2009/fs_50125005.pdf | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision1 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 1 | |dnd_section=FOI 1 | ||
|dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | |dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision2 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 10 | |dnd_section=FOI 10 | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision3 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 17 | |dnd_section=FOI 17 | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision4 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 40 | |dnd_section=FOI 40 | ||
|dnd_finding=Not upheld | |dnd_finding=Not upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision5 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 41 | |dnd_section=FOI 41 | ||
|dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | |dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision6 | ||
|dnd_section=FOI 43 | |dnd_section=FOI 43 | ||
|dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | |dnd_finding=Partly Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision7 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 5(1) | |dnd_section=EIR 5(1) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision8 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 5(2) | |dnd_section=EIR 5(2) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision9 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 12(4)(e) | |dnd_section=EIR 12(4)(e) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision10 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 12(5)(e) | |dnd_section=EIR 12(5)(e) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision11 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 12(5)(f) | |dnd_section=EIR 12(5)(f) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
{{ | {{DNDecision12 | ||
|dnd_section=EIR 14(3) | |dnd_section=EIR 14(3) | ||
|dnd_finding=Upheld | |dnd_finding=Upheld | ||
}} | }} | ||
Revision as of 22:26, 15 May 2010
Decision Summary
- Case Ref: FS50125005
- Date: 17 June 2009
- Public Authority: Trafford Metropolitan Borough Council
- Summary: The complainant requested information about a proposal to redevelop a shopping centre in the centre of a village, Hale Barns, in Cheshire. The council is the freeholder of the property which is held on a long term lease by the developer. The council provided some information to the complainant however it withheld other information under the exemptions in sections 43 (commercial interests), 41 (information held in confidence) and 40 (personal data) of the Act. It also withheld other information under Section 36 of the Act (the effective conduct of public affairs); however after it was directed by the Commissioner to reconsider this information under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 it amended this to Regulations 12(4)(e) (internal communications), 12(5)(e) (the confidentiality of commercial or industrial information) and 12(5)(f) (confidential information provided on a voluntary basis). The Commissioner's decision is that the council withheld some of information appropriately under sections 43, 40 and 41 but other information should have been disclosed. Under the Regulations his decision is that some information was appropriately withheld under Regulations 12(4)(e), 12(5)(e), and 12(5)(f) however other information could not be withheld under these Regulations.
- View PDF of Decision Notice: [1]
Template:DNDecision1 Template:DNDecision2 Template:DNDecision3 Template:DNDecision4 Template:DNDecision5 Template:DNDecision6 Template:DNDecision7 Template:DNDecision8 Template:DNDecision9 Template:DNDecision10 Template:DNDecision11 Template:DNDecision12
